Loyalist vs Klaviyo

Klaviyo reads your reservation book. Loyalist writes back to it.

Klaviyo now reads OpenTable, so a booking reaches the guest profile alongside the ecommerce data they have always been strongest at. What it cannot do is answer. Loyalist writes notes and tags back into the book before service, texts the guests it just segmented where Klaviyo can only email them, and reads Resy, SevenRooms and Tock instead of OpenTable alone.

Pick Klaviyo if

Klaviyo

A B2C marketing platform, strongest in ecommerce.

  1. 01A meaningful part of your revenue is e-commerce: merchandise, gift cards, meal kits, ticketing or a Shopify storefront.
  2. 02You want the widest channel set in one place, including mobile push and in-app, and a team that will use the automation depth.
  3. 03OpenTable is your only reservation platform, email is the only channel your guests need, and you would rather run the storefront and the dining room from one account.
Pick Loyalist if

Loyalist

The AI platform that turns guest data into revenue.

  1. 01You want one profile per guest, built from all your guest data, and campaigns that target covers, check average and what was ordered. Shopify orders land on the same profile, so the storefront and the dining room are one person.
  2. 02You want that depth without standing up a data team to get it. The profile assembles itself from the systems you already run, with no engineer and no warehouse in the middle.
  3. 03You want the campaign to reach the floor, not only the inbox. Notes and tags write back into Resy, SevenRooms and OpenTable, so the host greets the guest the send just targeted.
How they are built

Klaviyo and Loyalist, axis by axis.

Both unify guest data and message across channels, and both now read reservations. The split is the direction. A feed out of the book, or a record that writes back into it.

AxisKlaviyoLoyalist
Built around A customer profile from ecommerce and web events, with reservations and POS orders added through OpenTable. A guest profile from POS, reservations, reviews and private events, written back into the reservation book as well as read from it.
Who it is for Consumer brands across e-commerce, retail, wellness and subscription. Full-service hospitality groups, from one room to fifty locations.
Native integrations A large marketplace led by ecommerce and advertising, plus OpenTable, Toast, Square, Olo and Thanx for restaurants. Seventeen point-of-sale systems, five reservation platforms, plus reviews, listings, hotels and private events.
Who you can send to Any profile in the account, segmented on orders, browsing and completed reservations. OpenTable phone numbers arrive without SMS consent, so those guests cannot be texted. The guestbook, or a slice of it cut by covers, check average or time since a booking.
How results are counted Attributed revenue across channels, with predictive analytics. Visits and spend, tied to the journey that produced them.
Reservation platforms OpenTable, on an OpenTable Pro plan. Two years of history at setup. Resy, SevenRooms, OpenTable and Tock, loaded back to the first booking.
Where we overlap

Where the two overlap, and what usually happens next.

There is more overlap here than there was a year ago. Both read OpenTable, both put a reservation on the guest profile, and both can trigger a flow off a completed visit. Credit where it is due. The overlap stops at the read. Klaviyo takes data out of the book and turns it into a segment, and that is the end of what it can do with the room. Loyalist sends notes and tags back into the book before service, reaches the guests Klaviyo is not allowed to text, and covers the reviews, the listings and the private events that a restaurant would otherwise buy three more products to handle.

Both do this
  • Reservations, party size and check totals on the guest profile
  • Ecommerce orders landing on the guest profile, through Shopify
  • Email and SMS flows with branching logic
  • Point-of-sale orders, and the items a guest ordered, on the profile
Only Klaviyo
  • Onsite browse and cart-abandonment triggers, from their tracking script
Only Loyalist
  • Reservation data from Resy, SevenRooms and Tock, not OpenTable alone
  • Texting the guests the reservation book brought in
  • Notes and tags written back into the reservation book before service
  • Private dining booked by contract, landing on the guest record
  • A routed restaurant phone line that texts the caller a booking link
Where Loyalist is stronger

What you get with Loyalist.

What switching involves

Simple, guided migration

Our onboarding team does it with you, start to finish. You keep Klaviyo running until you decide otherwise, and there is no engineering project on your side.

  1. 01

    Connect your existing software platforms

    Your POS, reservation platform, ordering, events and reviews. Nothing to build on your side.

  2. 02

    Let Loyalist clean up your data

    Your history loads into the guest profiles you already have, cleaned of duplicates before anything merges.

  3. 03

    You brief the floor

    Notes and tags write back to your book, and the first pre-shift report lands before service.

From operators

Why operators love Loyalist.

Within two weeks the return on marketing outreach through Loyalist was so undeniably strong that there was no way we weren’t going to enroll the third restaurant.
Elizabeth Sharp Glendale Hospitality
That’s been especially valuable for private events, helping us reach the right audiences with the right message.
Ellen Yin High Street Hospitality Group
I have a better idea of who my guests are — who my best regulars are, who has not been back in a while, who loves wines, who comes to special events.
Cedric Nicaise The Noortwyck

Top restaurant groups use Loyalist daily:

  • Rose's Luxury
  • Crown Shy
  • Cosme
  • Le Bernardin
  • Daniel Boulud
  • COTE
FAQ
Coexistence

Can we keep Klaviyo and add Loyalist?

Yes, and it makes sense if you have a real online store. Klaviyo is not on our integrations hub today, so the two run side by side rather than syncing. Both will read your OpenTable bookings, so pick one place to send from and a guest will not get the same offer twice. In practice the dining room work ends up in Loyalist anyway, because that is the side that can text a guest, write back to the book and put a private event on the same record.

Sending

Does Loyalist send the email, or just decide who gets it?

Both, and WhatsApp as well, plus a VIP text line your team can answer. Klaviyo reaches further into mobile push and in-app. The difference that matters more is what decides who gets the message. Loyalist picks from spend, visit history, what they ordered and when they last booked, so a message can be narrow enough to be worth opening rather than a blast to everyone. The same record then reaches the floor, so the guest who got the email is recognized at the door and treated like the regular the data says they are.

Fit

When is Klaviyo the better choice?

When a large share of your revenue is transacted online rather than at a table. If merchandise, gift cards or meal kits are the growth story, they are built for that and we are not. Their OpenTable integration means the dining room is visible to them now, which is worth saying plainly. Visible is not the same as served: it reads one reservation platform, it cannot write anything back to the floor, and the guests it learns about there cannot be texted.

Fit

When is Loyalist the better choice?

When the dining room is the business rather than a channel. You want what marketing knows to reach the host stand before the guest sits down, which no amount of reading the book will do on its own. You want to text a segment as well as email it. You are on Resy, SevenRooms or Tock, or your point of sale is something other than Toast or Square. And you would rather have reviews, listings and private events on the same guest record than buy three more products to put them there.

Which is better

Which is better for a restaurant, Klaviyo or Loyalist?

For an ecommerce store, Klaviyo, comfortably. For a dining room, Loyalist, and the gap is wider than their OpenTable launch makes it look. Klaviyo can now see a booking, which it could not do last year. It still cannot act on one. It reads a single reservation platform, on a single plan tier, and nothing it learns goes back to the floor, so the host greeting that guest tonight knows none of it. Its own documentation rules out texting the diners it imports from OpenTable. And a restaurant running it still needs a reviews tool, a listings tool and an events system alongside it. Loyalist reads Resy, SevenRooms, Tock and OpenTable, writes notes and tags back before service, emails and texts the same guest, and carries reviews, listings and private dining in one product. If the dining room is the business, that is the difference between knowing about a guest and doing something about them.

Automations

Does Loyalist have flows and automations like Klaviyo?

Yes, with one difference worth knowing. A Klaviyo flow ends when the message is delivered. A Loyalist journey can also apply a tag or write a note back into your reservation book, so the host reading it tonight knows what the journey knew.

OpenTable

Klaviyo integrates with OpenTable now. What does Loyalist add?

The ability to act on what it reads. Klaviyo’s integration is a one-way feed, and their own documentation is clear about what that costs. It can read a booking but cannot write a note or a tag back, so nothing it knows ever reaches the host stand. Phone numbers sync without SMS consent, so the diners it imports can be emailed but never texted. It covers OpenTable alone, on an OpenTable Pro plan. Loyalist reads Resy, SevenRooms, Tock and OpenTable, writes back to all of them before service, and reaches the same guest by email or text. Around that sit the reviews, the listings, the private events and the guest record itself, in one product rather than four.

Both

We run ecommerce as well as restaurants. What then?

Keep Klaviyo for the store. The two are not on the same integrations hub today, so they run side by side rather than syncing, and each covers the surface it was built for.

The check

Can Loyalist see what a guest actually ordered?

Yes, where the point of sale exposes it. That is what makes a segment like "spent over $200 on wine in the last six months" possible without anybody tagging guests by hand. Klaviyo reads item-level orders too, from Toast and Square. The difference is how much of the market that covers. Seventeen point-of-sale systems are on the Loyalist integrations hub.

Keep researching

Evaluate Loyalist against Klaviyo with an AI agent and see which one fits your business better.

Get started with Loyalist.

If your hospitality group is looking to supercharge your data, we’d love to chat.